Utah County won't prosecute Sister Wives for bigamy

Prosecutors' new policy includes tossing suit vs. "Sister Wives" family.

The Salt Lake Tribune/June 1, 2012

A polygamous family made famous by a reality TV show won't face criminal charges, Utah County Attorney Jeff Buhman said Thursday.

The office has adopted a formal policy stating it won't file bigamy charges against any consenting adult polygamists unless violence, abuse or fraud is involved.

It is "intended to prevent future prosecution of polygamists in Utah County for just the practice of polygamy," now or in the future, even after Buhman leaves office.

The statements are part of a motion to dismiss a challenge to the state's bigamy law filed by Kody Brown and his four wives: Meri, Janelle, Christine and Robyn.

Buhman says an investigation found no other crimes and charges wouldn't be filed unless some other new evidence surfaces. He argues the new policy renders the suit moot.

An attorney for the Brown family disagreed.

"While I am pleased that the prosecutors are now promising to leave this family alone, the decision will not end our challenge to the state law," said Washington, D.C.-based attorney Jonathan Turley in a blog entry posted Thursday, expressing his "great relief for the Brown family that this long-standing threat has been finally lifted."

The Browns say the bigamy law, which makes it a felony to marry or live with more than one than one spouse, violates their constitutional right to privacy and religious freedom. They filed their own 71-page motion for summary judgement Thursday.

When the TLC show Sister Wives debuted in 2010, Utah County prosecutors announced they were investigating the then-Lehi residents and gave several media interviews. A federal judge decided the possible "chilling effect" on the family's free speech allowed the lawsuit to go forward even though formal charges hadn't been filed.

Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff, whose office wrote Thursday's motion, has long had a similar policy of not prosecuting consenting adult polygamists. That policy led the judge to dismiss him from the Browns' lawsuit earlier this year.

Utah County is the first county to adopt such a policy, but prosecutions of consenting adults absent of other crimes has been a rarity in the state for half a century. Prosecutions of Utah's most high profile polygamists — Tom Green and sect leader Warren Jeffs — have involved sex crime allegations.

To see more documents/articles regarding this group/organization/subject click here.