Researcher Takes Aim at Alien Abductions

New Brisbane's News 1 (Australia)/October 15, 2005
By Michael Kunzelman

Cambridge, Mass. - Susan Clancy is sick of space aliens. The Harvard psychologist figures she has read every book and seen every movie ever made about extraterrestrials, and she has interviewed roughly 50 people who claim to have been abducted by aliens.

"I have become a reluctant scholar of alienography," Clancy said.

Those who believe aliens are among us haven‘t taken kindly to her theory that abductees have created "false memories" out of, she writes, a "blend of fantasy-proneness, memory distortion, culturally available scripts, sleep hallucinations, and scientific illiteracy."

"Arguing weird beliefs is a very normal thing," she said in a telephone interview from Nicaragua, where she has a research job. "It‘s very human for us to believe in things for which there is no scientific evidence."

She quickly found herself the target of angry "outsiders" who accused her of trying to discredit victims. One irate letter-writer called her a "friend of pedophiles everywhere."

Mack‘s work gave Clancy an idea: Wouldn‘t it be easier to test her theories if she could be certain that her subjects‘ memories were not real? She and her adviser, Harvard psychologist Richard McNally, placed a newspaper ad that asked, "Have you been abducted by aliens?" It took less than a day for callers to fill her voice mail.

To the Harvard psychologists, it was obvious that their subjects had suffered an episode of sleep paralysis — a state of limbo between sleep and being awake, sometimes punctuated by hallucinations.

Many of the abductees also could be described as "spiritual people" who have abandoned conventional religious beliefs, McNally added.

In her book, Clancy describes her subjects‘ stories of abduction in detail, changing only their names.

Another subject, a 34-year-old artist with a college education, couldn‘t put a finger on her "disturbing sleep-related experiences" until he was hypnotized by an abduction researcher he found on the Internet.

During his second hypnosis session, the artist said he recovered memories of being abducted by aliens who strapped him down on a black marble table and subjected him to a painful sexual experiment.

Clancy said a wealth of research shows that hypnosis makes it easier for people to create false memories.

"This is in large part because it both stimulates the imagination and relaxes reality constraints," she writes in her book.

However, Clancy learned it was impossible to categorically disprove alien abductions.

"All you can do is argue that they‘re improbable and that the evidence adduced by the believer is insufficient to justify the belief," she wrote. "Ultimately, then, the existence of ETs is a matter of opinion, and the believers have their own opinions, based on firsthand experience."

One of those "believers" is Will Bueche, a 36-year-old Arlington resident who was working for Mack when Clancy and McNally interviewed him several years ago.

Bueche said he has had more than a dozen "encounters" with aliens since he was a young child. These encounters with the "pale, thin beings," he said, usually happen at night, in his room, and he feels alert but "a little bit drugged" while they communicate with him telepathically.

"It‘s not like they‘re speaking English in my mind," he said. "It‘s a mixture of music, pictures, feelings and impressions."

Bueche said Clancy‘s theories about alien abductions, including sleep paralysis, cannot fully explain what he‘s experienced.

"I think her book comes close to the truth in many ways, but it isn‘t able to see the potential out there for another breakthrough in how we see reality," he said.

Clancy‘s conclusions aren‘t shared by David Jacobs, an associate professor of history at Temple University. Jacobs, who teaches a class called "UFOs and American Society," said Clancy‘s "Abducted" is a "typical debunking book."

"This is junk social science, and there is a certain condescending quality to it," he said.

Jacobs, who said he has used "hypnotic regression" to recover memories from more than 900 alien abductees, said sleep paralysis, faulty hypnosis and false memories "simply do not account for the convincing details" in abductees‘ stories.

"All debunkers make one or more of the following mistakes: They ignore the data, they distort the data or they don‘t know the data," he said, describing himself as a "serious UFO researcher who believes the evidence is compelling that these events are happening more or less as (abductees) say."

Clancy and McNally aren‘t the only psychologists who have studied alien abductees.

Leonard Newman, a psychology professor at the University of Illinois at Chicago, is the co-author of a paper that argued alien abductees are "masochists" who enjoy the painful experiences they describe.

"These people are not lying," Newman said. "False memories feel as real as real memories."

Unlike Clancy and McNally, Newman did not interview any abductees firsthand, relying instead on other published accounts of abduction reports. Newman said many of his colleagues thought he was foolish to tackle the subject matter.

"Probably it‘s just too darn weird for some people," he said of his masochism theory. "It‘s like explaining one weird phenomenon with another that people find weird."

Clancy shares Newman‘s reluctance to make a career out of alien abductions. She said the volume and nasty tone of the hate mail she gets these days is far worse than what her research on sexual-abuse victims generated. In July, for instance, she appeared on CNN‘s "Larry King Live" and started receiving nasty e-mails before the show was even over.

"I‘m done with aliens," she said.